Neighbor Dispute Turns Horrific as Woman Suffers Chemical Burns

Police records say the women had a history of problems before an October confrontation left one neighbor with serious injuries.

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — A two-year history of disputes between Fort Lauderdale neighbors preceded an October confrontation in which police say one woman threw a boiling liquid at the other, causing severe chemical burns and an immediate loss of vision in her right eye.

The allegations are detailed in an arrest warrant for Tracy Nicole Williams, 39, who was taken into custody Thursday and appeared before a Broward County judge Friday. Police charged Williams with aggravated battery causing great bodily harm and felony criminal mischief. She received a $12,500 bond and was ordered to have no contact with the neighbor. Williams has not been convicted of the charges.

According to the warrant, the neighbor told investigators that she had lived next to Williams for about two years and that problems between them had been ongoing. Police records cited in the warrant documented several previous incidents. Authorities did not provide complete details about those earlier encounters, and the existence of prior reports does not establish responsibility for the latest allegations.

The confrontation under investigation happened at about 9:30 p.m. Oct. 13 outside a small group of duplexes in the 2500 block of Northwest 20th Street, police said. The neighbor told investigators that Williams confronted her and accused her of damaging a vehicle. The woman denied damaging it. Police allege Williams later filled a bucket with a boiling liquid and threw it at her.

The victim told investigators that the liquid felt extremely hot and produced an additional burning sensation. She also reported smelling bleach. Police records did not establish exactly what chemical was in the liquid, and authorities described bleach only as a possibility. The woman said she immediately could not see through her right eye and went into her home to rinse her face.

While trying to clean the substance from herself, the woman noticed that her shirt began changing color, according to the warrant. Police said she later reported that the burning and pain became severe enough that she sought medical care. The warrant said multiple medical evaluations concluded that she had suffered a severe chemical burn and that her condition worsened after initial swelling and redness.

Medical treatment was still continuing when investigators prepared the warrant, and the full extent of the injuries was not known. The police account did not say whether the woman eventually recovered vision in her right eye. No later verified medical update was available in the reporting reviewed Saturday.

The dispute also allegedly continued around the woman’s vehicle. Police said she told investigators that she watched security cameras from inside her home and saw neighbors damaging the vehicle with a baseball bat while she was washing her eye. Williams was accused of breaking the vehicle’s taillights. The woman also reported discoloration where the liquid struck the vehicle and said a chemical odor remained inside it.

Authorities had not announced whether anyone besides Williams would face charges related to the reported vehicle damage. The available police records do not establish who else may have participated, and no additional arrest was confirmed in the latest reporting.

Fort Lauderdale police arrested Williams after officers spotted her driving Thursday and recognized that she had an active warrant, according to an arrest report. Police first saw her in the 700 block of West Sunrise Boulevard and stopped her in the 300 block of East Las Olas Boulevard.

At her Friday court appearance, prosecutors requested $15,000 in total bond. Williams’ attorney sought $6,000, pointing to her limited financial resources, plans to begin working and responsibility for supporting her children. Broward Judge Allison Gilman set bond at $12,500 and imposed a no-contact order that requires Williams to avoid the neighbor even if they encounter each other near their homes.

The criminal case remains pending. Williams was still being held at the Broward Main Jail as of late Friday morning, while questions remained about the neighbor’s long-term recovery and whether authorities would bring any additional charges arising from the Oct. 13 confrontation.

Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.