Man accused of shooting three tourists to death in Kissimmee

Prosecutors and defense spar over whether the jail refusal signals illness or defiance.

OSCEOLA COUNTY, Fla. — A judge ordered a psychiatric evaluation for a man accused of fatally shooting three tourists near Kissimmee after he refused to come to court for a hearing where he was expected to enter a plea, delaying a case that has drawn attention across Central Florida.

The defendant, 29-year-old Ahmad Jihad Bojeh, is accused of shooting three men outside a short-term rental home in January in what investigators have called a random attack. His public defender asked the court to determine whether he is competent to proceed. Prosecutors urged a fast decision, warning that the case could stall for months or longer if Bojeh is found unable to take part in his own defense.

The missed court appearance happened Feb. 18, when Bojeh was scheduled to appear in Osceola County for a hearing tied to the triple-homicide case. Instead, the judge told the courtroom that Bojeh refused to be transported from the jail. Assistant State Attorney Peter Donnelly said the refusal followed a pattern, telling the judge that when a mental-health expert came to evaluate Bojeh, he would not get up, leaving doctors unable to complete their work. Donnelly argued the behavior should not be treated like a choice. He said Bojeh was able to get up for meals and to use the bathroom, but still refused court and evaluation steps. The state asked the judge to order that Bojeh be brought to future hearings by any reasonable means, so the case can move forward.

Public defender Alesha Smith pushed back, saying a sweeping order could harm her client emotionally or psychologically, especially if he resists. Smith told the judge she did not know what exactly was behind the refusal on that day and asked the court to handle transport decisions case by case. The judge declined to issue a blanket order forcing Bojeh into court for every hearing. Instead, the judge appointed a psychiatrist to examine him and set the next step for April, when the court expects to review his mental health status and decide how to proceed.

At the center of the delay is a legal question with major consequences: whether Bojeh understands the charges against him and can help his attorney. Competency is different from an insanity defense. A competency finding focuses on the defendant’s current mental state and ability to take part in court. If a judge finds Bojeh incompetent, the criminal case cannot move forward until competency is restored. That often means treatment in a state facility, and in some cases the pause can last a long time as doctors report back to the court.

Investigators say the shootings happened Jan. 17 in the Indian Point area near Kissimmee, where the victims were staying at an Airbnb-style rental on Indian Point Circle. Authorities have said the three men were in town for the Mecum Auto Auction and had no known connection to Bojeh, who lived next door. The victims were identified as Robert Kraft, Douglas Kraft and James Puchan, all older adults visiting from out of state. Sheriff Christopher Blackmon previously described the attack as senseless and said deputies quickly took a suspect into custody, telling the community there was no continuing threat after the arrest.

The case also revived scrutiny of an earlier shooting involving Bojeh. Records and prior reporting describe a 2021 incident at a Wawa in Kissimmee where shots were fired at what authorities said were random cars, and a man was wounded. Bojeh was later found not guilty by reason of insanity in that case. Court orders tied to such findings often include conditions meant to reduce risk, such as treatment requirements and limits on weapons. In the current homicide case, prosecutors and local leaders have repeatedly pointed back to the earlier case as they try to explain how the latest violence happened and what steps could have prevented it.

Newer filings in the homicide case add another layer: charging decisions. In early court steps, Bojeh faced first-degree murder accusations, but later paperwork filed by prosecutors charged him with three counts of second-degree murder, with the possibility that a grand jury could still consider upgrading charges. The difference matters because first-degree murder requires proof of premeditation, while second-degree murder can involve a “depraved mind” without a proven plan. Prosecutors have said they are reviewing evidence carefully as the case moves through the system.

Investigators have described evidence that includes firearms and ammunition linked to the crime scene. Deputies wrote in court documents that two pistols were found during searches, and investigators have said the victims appeared to have been shot multiple times. Authorities have not announced a clear motive. They have repeatedly said there was no known conflict between Bojeh and the three men. That absence of a motive, along with the prior history of mental illness claims, is part of what is now shaping the legal path. A competency ruling could come before the public ever hears a full outline of what detectives believe led to the shootings.

Families and community members have watched the court process closely. The victims were visitors, but the case landed hard in Central Florida because it involved a short-term rental in a neighborhood where residents expected quiet weekends, not gunfire. The tourist corridor around Kissimmee and Orlando is built on visitors arriving for theme parks, conventions and events, and law enforcement officials have said they want to show that serious crimes will be investigated quickly and prosecuted fully. At the same time, defense attorneys and mental health advocates often stress that courts must follow the rules around competency and treatment, even in cases involving severe allegations.

For now, the key question is what doctors can determine if a defendant refuses to cooperate. Prosecutors have argued that Bojeh’s pattern of refusal should not be allowed to stop the court from making a decision. Defense attorneys have signaled that forcing a noncompliant defendant into hearings can backfire and can worsen a mental health crisis. Judges are left balancing safety, due process and the need for a fair trial that can withstand appeal. In Florida, competency restoration often involves evaluation, treatment plans and periodic hearings where doctors report whether the defendant has improved enough to move forward.

The April hearing set by the court is expected to be a major checkpoint. If the psychiatrist finds Bojeh competent, the case can return to the usual path: arraignment, plea entry, motions, and eventually a trial date. If he is found incompetent, the court could order him sent to a state facility for treatment aimed at restoring competency, with later hearings to review progress. Either way, prosecutors have said they want a decision quickly so the case does not sit in limbo.

Author note: Last updated Feb. 19, 2026.