FRANKFORT, Ky. — In an unsettling incident that gripped the small Appalachian community of Whitesburg, a local judge was fatally shot in his courthouse chambers Thursday, with the sheriff of Letcher County charged with his murder. The violent altercation inside the courthouse, which serves a population of about 1,700, has left the tight-knit town in shock and mourning.
Kentucky State Police reported that Sheriff Shawn M. Stines is accused of shooting District Judge Kevin Mullins multiple times following a heated dispute. Mullins, a respected figure who had been on the bench for 15 years, died at the scene. Stines, 43, subsequently surrendered to authorities and is now facing a charge of first-degree murder. The investigation continues as the community seeks answers to the tragic event.
In response to the shooting, the courthouse was ordered closed the following day by Letcher County’s judge-executive, reflecting the gravity of the situation and its impact on the county’s administrative operations.
The case has also prompted legal recusals and a shift in prosecutorial responsibilities due to the close personal and familial connections within the community. The lead county prosecutor, Matt Butler, announced his recusal, citing his familial ties to Mullins, which include shared family relations through marriage and their children who are closely connected.
Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman has pledged his office’s full cooperation, stating that they will work diligently alongside a commonwealth’s attorney from a neighboring district to ensure a thorough investigation and the pursuit of justice.
The Kentucky Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice Laurance B. VanMeter, expressed profound disturbance over the incident, highlighting the broader implications for judicial and community safety.
This tragic event underscores the challenges faced by small, interconnected communities where professional and personal lives often intertwine. Governor Andy Beshear lamented the broader issue of rising violence, expressing on social media his hope for a more peaceful future.
Judge Mullins, aged 54, had been a prominent judicial figure since his initial appointment in 2009 by former Governor Steve Beshear. He was known for his advocacy and implementation of substance abuse treatment programs within the judicial system. He played a significant role in developing Addiction Recovery Care, which provides peer support services, and has been implemented in over 50 Kentucky counties.
Mullins’ efforts extended beyond his judicial duties, as he was also a founding member of the Responsive Effort to Support Treatment in Opioid Recovery Efforts Leadership Team. He was recognized for his commitment to helping residents access inpatient residential treatment, notably speaking at a drug summit in 2022 regarding the impact of these initiatives.
The loss of Judge Mullins and the circumstances surrounding his death have undoubtedly left a void in Letcher County, highlighting the profound impact that individual community leaders can have on public service, safety, and community well-being. As the investigation moves forward, the community of Whitesburg and broader Kentucky hold close to their memories of service and await answers in this distressing case.